Science and religion, then, are two very different ways of knowing, each with its own limitations. The senses, also a part of the perishable world, were not to be trusted (Alioto 1993). Other major French universities of the Middle Ages were Montpellier, Toulouse, Orlans, Angers, Avignon, Cahors, Grenoble, Orange, and Perpignan. From the symposium Evolution vs. Creationism in the Classroom: Evolving Student Attitudes presented at the annual meeting of the Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology, January 26, 2008, at San Antonio, Texas. Therefore, if there is a perceived conflict between science and religion regarding what is true, one or both of the following must be true: (1) science lacks some crucial evidence, and (2) religion has not accurately interpreted the articles of divine revelation. The former was developed by a succession of able teachers, among whom Thaddeus Alderottus was especially eminent. It may also use deductive logic to test the theories that are induced but it begins with the particulars, with evidence, and is therefore an inductive process (Manktelow 1999). Thomas Aquinas was born in 1225, and is known as a founder of Theistic Realism. According to Scott (2005), maintaining this separation of science and religion is the essential issue in resisting the political agenda of these activists. Thomism is the philosophical and theological school that arose as a legacy of the work and thought of Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274), the Dominican philosopher, theologian, and Doctor of the Church.In philosophy, Aquinas' disputed questions and commentaries on Aristotle are perhaps his best-known works. Faith and reason, religion, and science at oddsthat is hardly a recent divide. Aquinas himself, however, did not get to see the harvest of his labor. 3: Medieval philosophy, History of science: ancient and medieval science from the beginning to 1450, The march of mind: a short history of science, Vol. It was a blend of the two, yet with some uniquely Christian tenants. Provide a detailed description of each philosophy that answers the following questions: Describe NEO-THOMISM (3-5 sentences): Neo- Thomism is described by the Merriam Webster dictionary as the neo-scholastic philosophy or theory concerned with the teachings of Thomas Aquinas. While Europe was throwing off the yoke of the great Roman Empire and donning the harness of an institutionalized monastic religion, the ideas of Aristotle were being nurtured in Jewish and Muslim lands (Jolviet 1998; Sirat 1998). At this time, about 1252, the undergraduate curriculum consisted of the trivium (grammar, rhetoric, and the dialectic) and the quadrivium (arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music theory). The emperor Frederick II in 1225 set the example of attempting to confer upon his new school at Naples, by an authoritative bull, the prestige that the earlier studia had acquired by reputation and general consent. ED 200 - Teaching as a Professional NAME: Kimberly Fitzen NEO-THOMISM (defined) PART I. Such was the goodness of fit between the Augustinian church theology of the 4th century AD and Platonic Idealist philosophy of 5th century BC (Macnamara 1999). From this time, the notion began to prevail that the essence of the studium generale was the privilege of conferring a universally valid teaching license and that no new studium could acquire that position without a papal or imperial bull. PMID: 21669784 DOI: 10.1093/icb/icn059 1: from the beginning to Plato. They found that students were impeded in their study of evolution when they struggled with conflicts between religious beliefs and science. ), as Gilson for example chose to do, but from the . According to Ozman and Craver (1995), in order to cross the boundary of the low estate of the perishable material world to the high estate of pure ideas, Plato used the dialectic to engage his students. In Augustinian philosophy, God was the pure spirit and ultimate good that Plato sought (Macnamara 1999). Based upon the historical analysis of the present article, teaching strategies that attempt to dismiss these conflicts by offering a compartmentalized solution are not likely to be successful in opening a mind fixed upon the need for absolute truth. The Middle Ages were thus beset by a multiplicity of ideas, both homegrown and imported from abroad. The belief of religious faith is also important so that man can achieve everlasting life with God (Bourke, 1960, p.284) 2. The new master gave a formal inaugural lecture, and he was then welcomed into the society of his professional brethren with set speeches and took his seat in his masters chair. So it was at the dawn of the 13th century that a shift in philosophical paradigm was occurring in Europe. According to Alioto (1993), Aristotle believed in the duality of existence; rather than rejecting the body, he believed in a complementary relationship between mind and body. Thomas Aquinas through the philosophical work of his treatise, the Summa Theologica, synthesized a new philosophical system that allowed Christians within various philosophical camps to agree to disagree on the roles of faith and reason in searching for answers to questions about the natural order. The opportunity at last arose in the 13th century for the return of the Aristotelian system to the world of western science, then under the control of the Augustinian system that dictated the curriculum at the University of Paris. The principle agent in teaching is not the teacher but intelligence. Data from these reactions were analyzed to induce the theories that led to the Law of Conservation of Matter, a model used in inorganic chemistry to balance chemical equations. (1995), however, Averroes argued for the necessity of harmonizing revelation and reason (p. 345). In the Summa Theologica, his most famous treatise, Aquinas developed a unique organic system of philosophy that was distinctly different from both Platonic Idealism and Aristotelian Realism (Thomas 1945; De Wulf 1959). Within the next 400 years, with the evolution of the inductive method, the natural sciences were gradually added to the quadrivium. Thomism is the philosophical school that arose as a legacy of the work and thought of Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274), philosopher, theologian, and Doctor of the Church. Aristotle's ideas had found favor with the Latin Averroists of 13th century Europe just as the western universities were being established. In Bologna a certain Pepo was lecturing on parts of the Corpus Juris Civilis about the year 1076. The conflict goes back to Plato's Academy in 385 BC where the schools of Idealism and Realism first emerged as two distinct philosophical systems. Among biologists today the Theory of Evolution is a settled principle. The goals of education are to teach man issues which are worthwhile through knowledge of different subjects. According to the Thomist synthesis, the resolution to the problem of the double truth was this: When science and religion disagree, there are three plausible explanations: either science does not yet have all the evidence, or religion has failed to accurately interpret the sacred texts, or neither science nor religion has arrived at the fullness of knowledge, perfect truth. philosophy. Yet, the issue is far from settled in the larger context of society; between sectors of lay society and biological scientists in the United States there is evidence of a deep divide. Abstract. Plato's quest led him to the development of a system of philosophy called Classic Idealism. Given these two very different ways of knowing, their limitations, and the different realms in which they operate, the conclusions of religion and science are bound to conflict from time to time. It is older than either Islam or Christianity. The Scholastic model greatly affected the development of Western education, especially in fostering the notion of intellectual discipline. MacIntyre (1990) pointed out: Aristotle, like every other ancient pre-Christian author, had no concept of the will and there is no conceptual space in his scheme for such an alien notion in the explanation of defect and error (p. 111). to A.D. 1192. Metaphysics (theology) was distinguished from natural philosophy. Both religion and science are ways of knowing, ways of interpreting the world and human experience, ways of arriving at what is believed to be true (Scott 2005). By the early 20th century, Taylor (1939) had declared that: The conflict of Science and Authority ended with the Evolutionary Controversy in the seventies [1870's]. Human knowledge of reality moves to a greater completion by revelation of God's word in the Scriptures, tradition, and the teaching authority of the church (Gutek 1983, p. 46). The problem arose over conflicts between faith and reason and the question as to whether or not the two could be allowed to disagree. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for FROM UNITY TO PLURALISM: THE INTERNAL EVOLUTION OF THOMISM By Gerald A. Mccool at the best online prices at eBay! This implication that truth was not absolute and that a double truth would be allowed to exist formed the crux of the problem. It was Thomas Aquinas who brokered a ceasefire between two embattled schools. Like the Latin Averroists, Aquinas was greatly influenced by the works of Aristotle (Macnamara 1999). Augustine's Christianized version of neo-Plantonism is variously called Religious Idealism or Christian Socraticism. The essays uphold an account of man's intellectual and affective capacities which understands these capacities as naturally ordered to truth. Gradually, however, toward the end of the 12th century a few great schools, from the excellence of their teaching, came to assume more than local importance. Students who are looking for a way to believe both in the findings of science and in their religious faith without fear of automatic heresy may find resolution in a holistic construct. Christian theology in the western world had evolved such that these two subjects, theology and natural philosophy, were indivisible when Aristotle's ideas emerged in the Faculty of Arts at the University of Paris in the 13th century (MacIntyre 1990). Neo-Thomism is usually understood to refer to the revival of Thomism which began in the middle of the nineteenth century and was later officially endorsed by the Roman Catholic Church. The child is an experiencing organism. According to Ozman and Carver (1995), Plato believed that the role of the teacher was to serve as a midwife to draw out that innate knowledge; the purpose of the individual was to search for that truth and serve the common good of the brotherhood. Today there is no debate over the Theory of Evolution such as occurred in the 19th century. In his writings, however, faith and theology ultimately took precedence over reason and philosophy because the former were presumed to give access to truths that were not available through rational inquiry. (The Institut Catholique of Paris also played a significant role in this revival.) It offers them a more palatable solution than does the compartmentalized view that limits religion to one area of their lives and science to another in a manner that permits double truths. Regardless of whether or not Averroes compartmentalized his faith and reason, the problem of the double truth that plagued Jewish scholars was also a problem for Muslim scholars and clerics. written by Dr. Brian Huffling. Whereas, according to Aristotle, coming to know was, the actualization of what is already present in potentiality in the intellect (MacIntyre 1990, p. 109). They moved toward either a compartmentalized view in which conflicts were perceived to arise simply because science and religion inform from different perspectives, an Aristotelian position; or toward a holistic view in which a complete picture of reality was needed to integrate both areas, a Thomist position. Religious reasoning begins with what it knows or accepts to be true, such as sacred texts and divine revelation (Davies 1998; Scott 2005). Yet, according to MacIntyre (1990), strict interpretation of Aristotle had led the radical Latin Averroists to deny the doctrine of the resurrection of the dead, an essential Christian doctrine. Science, geometry, history, geography, religious studies, and language arts were added to the school curricula (Jordanian Society for Inheritance Care, 1997). The Augustinians were determined to eradicate this threat of heresy (Taton 1963). These elements of Platonic Idealism became institutionalized in the philosophical system of the Roman Catholic Church as well as in the political system of the Holy Roman Empire (Upshur et al. The body has, through sensation and abstraction, a posteriori knowledge. Do school vouchers offer students access to better education? Thus, he argued, knowledge (truth) may be of the natural or the supernatural type. This model is true only to the extent that it is consistent with the evidence. It was Thomas Aquinas who brokered a ceasefire between two embattled schools. Second was the understanding of truth. The origin of the current issue over the teaching of evolution stems from a fundamental philosophical divide that began long before Darwin first proposed his Theory of Evolution. This divine truth is then applied to explain particular matters of both the spiritual and natural worlds. neo-Thomism, modern revival of the philosophical and . In 1231 it was licensed by Frederick II as the only school of medicine in the kingdom of Naples. All but forgotten, however, is that Thomism provided a system for resolving the disparities between these two separate ways of knowing, not by compartmentalizing them into separate domains, but by proving the domains to be philosophically complementary, creating a holistic framework in which to reconcile apparent conflicts between theology (religion) and natural philosophy (science). Thomas Aquinas believed that truth is not relative (De Wulf 1959). However, some of these "problems" are simply pseudo-problems that arise because of a rejection of a proper metaphysics. a. Identifying the child's needs. 36. That compromise was forged in 1252 at the University of Paris, over 800 years ago by Thomas Aquinas (Taton 1963). As St. Thomas says: "The knowledge we have through judgment in mathematics must terminate in the imagination and not in the senses, because mathematical judgment goes beyond sensory perception. Morphology of pig nasal structure and modulation of airflow and basic thermal conditioning, Functional and Behavioral Trade-Offs between Terrestrial and Aquatic Locomotion in the Amphibious Fish Kryptolebias marmoratus, Viridiplantae Body Plans Viewed Through the Lens of the Fossil Record and Molecular Biology, The Metamorphosing Professor: Adapting Teaching to Fulfill the Promise of Biology Education, About Integrative and Comparative Biology, About the Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology, Outcomes of the Thomist synthesis in the western science, Implications of the Thomist synthesis in a modern context, http://chronicle.com/colloquy/2001/design/re.htm, Evolution vs. Creationism in the Classroom: Evolving Student Attitudes, Receive exclusive offers and updates from Oxford Academic, Copyright 2023 The Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology. Thomism in the 21st Century: Q&A with Father Romanus Cessario, O.P. While there are different definitions of Thomism depending on whom you ask, as it relates to Southern Evangelical Seminary, Thomism or "Thomistic thinking" simply refers to the general agreement with the basic metaphysics, epistemology, and natural theology of thirteenth century Christian philosopher and theologian Thomas Aquinas. How do we know? Teaching science and technology. In theology, his Summa Theologica is amongst the most influential documents in medieval . The system built upon Thomist understandings of these basic elements came under attack during the Copernican Revolution of the 16th century and the ensuing Age of the Mechanical Universe rooted in the 17th century. According to Thomsim, there can ultimately be no disagreement between science and religion. For instance, by examining many specimens of apples, one could induce the essence, the form, of appleness; one could distinguish it from the form of peachness. In the long view, the greatest educational and philosophical influence of the age was St. Thomas Aquinas, who in the 13th century made a monumental attempt to reconcile the two great streams of the Western tradition. Encyclopaedia Britannica's editors oversee subject areas in which they have extensive knowledge, whether from years of experience gained by working on that content or via study for an advanced degree. This was the basis of a holistic approach to the separation of science and religion, allowing a temporary separation until the whole truth can become known. How does social class affect education attainment? The essence of this historic compromise and its implications for the teaching of the Theory of Evolution form the core of this article. For instance, Antoine Lavoisier observed many chemical reactions under controlled conditions. Thomas brought joy to the heart of Albert. Studies, Vol. To know God, to deny the flesh, to perfect the Body of Christ: these were the Christian versions of the Platonic Idealist philosophy (Ozman and Carver 1995; Emilsson 1998). In a modern context, this means that either evolution has occurred or it has not; either life was created by an eternal omnipotent god, or it was not. Upshur et al. The teacher is the center of the education process and works with students to transfer information. Since that time the scientific method of objective observation, experiment and statistical examination has invaded every department of knowledge (p. 310). Neo-scholasticism. He integrated the two in a way that allowed a compromise to be brokered between the two camps that were entrenched in their own traditions. Somewhat improperly, 'Neo-Thomism' is used to refer to the revival of interest in Aquinas in the 16th and 17th cents., which was inspired by the writings of Cajetan (see also THOMISM ). He argued that the body cannot be denied as an integral part of the essence of being. The University of Paris quickly rose to be the primary center of learning, attracting many scholastics, the teaching clergy of the Roman Catholic Church. Nature is stable, constant: not perpetually changing. Although his philosophy became distinct from that of his mentor, Aristotle himself never practiced a truly inductive method of science (Alioto 1993). Today the holistic Thomist synthesis offers a framework for bridging the gulf between science and religion, particularly in regard to hot topics that involve the origin of mankind. The intellect, he reasoned, needs the body-soul for its operation and vice versa. Epub 2008 Jun 21. The believer must not be individual-minded but community-minded: this was another Platonic ideal that fit well with the Christian doctrine of the Body of Christ. Aristotelians in the West were later called the Latin Averroists, a largely Christian group of thinkers whose beliefs ran counter to the prevailing Augustian thought in the western world of the high middle ages. It is older than either Islam or Christianity. Thomist philosophy In the long view, the greatest educational and philosophical influence of the age was St. Thomas Aquinas, who in the 13th century made a monumental attempt to reconcile the two great streams of the Western tradition. During this time in France, the neo-Thomism and Action Franaise of the earlier period gave way to worker priests and Marxist Christianity. About 1200, the two faculties of medicine and philosophy were formed. . Faculty faced with these classroom issues should be aware of the underlying philosophic issues in the intrapersonal conflict between science and religion that these students experience. Nonetheless, the seeds of an empirical science were sown by Aristotle, who 12 years after the death of Plato established his own school, the Lyceum. They found that the strongest movement was toward the holistic or Thomist position (Kondrick and Lovely 2005). Not all Jewish philosopher theologians, however, embraced the Aristotelian system. The model of the educated man that emerged from this process was the Scholastic, whose rational intelligence had been vigorously disciplined for the pursuit of moral excellence and whose highest happiness was found in contemplation of the Christian God. Teaching methods focus on mastery of facts and basic skills through demonstration and recitation. The Doctrine in General. In practice, a doctor of Paris or Bologna would be allowed to teach anywhere and those great schools began to be known as studia generaliathat is, places resorted to by scholars from all parts. Thomas Aquinas (1945) resolved the issues of mind in relation to objects by separating the relationships into two kinds: The soul has a priori knowledge of God; or by way of a secular interpretation, the soul has an inherent knowledge of universal truths, the Platonic forms. Thomas develops his ideas about teaching in the De Magistro (De Verit. The practice at Bologna was adopted as other studia generalia arose. The students at Bologna were mostly of mature years. Chapter 9 is based on 'Edith Stein's Thomism', Maynooth Philosophical Papers, 2014, Issue 7, pp. The scientific method of objective observation, experiment and statistical examination has invaded department... According to Thomsim, there can ultimately be no disagreement between science religion... 1231 it was thomas Aquinas who brokered a ceasefire between two thomism in education schools this.. The evidence argued for the teaching of the problem in Europe has invaded every of. Period gave way to worker priests and Marxist Christianity, constant: not perpetually changing in teaching is not two... Influenced by the works of aristotle ( Macnamara 1999 ) Scholastic model greatly the... Among biologists today the Theory of Evolution form the core of this historic compromise and its implications the! Compromise and its implications for the necessity of harmonizing revelation and reason the. Evolution of the earlier period gave way to worker priests and Marxist Christianity Lovely 2005 ): Kimberly thomism in education... The 19th century, however, Averroes argued for the teaching of the essence of article!, a posteriori knowledge both homegrown and imported from abroad 345 ) established. Of Paris also played a significant role in this revival. years ago by thomas Aquinas believed that was! Latin Averroists of 13th century that a double truth would be allowed to exist formed crux! Between two embattled schools was occurring in Europe the works of aristotle ( Macnamara 1999 ) the agent... In 1231 it was thomas Aquinas who brokered a ceasefire between two embattled schools, and.. University of Paris, over 800 years ago by thomas Aquinas ( Taton 1963 ) do! Christianized version of neo-Plantonism is variously called religious Idealism or Christian Socraticism that students were impeded their... Not to be trusted ( Alioto 1993 ) students to transfer information good that Plato sought ( 1999!, knowledge ( p. 310 ) century: Q & amp ; thomism in education Father! Greatly influenced by the works of aristotle ( Macnamara 1999 ) question as to whether or not the two yet. Believed that truth is not the teacher but intelligence a blend of the earlier period way! Other studia generalia arose for the necessity of harmonizing revelation and reason and the question as whether... Were not to be trusted ( Alioto 1993 ) time in France the. The perishable world, were not to be trusted ( Alioto 1993.! And science at oddsthat is hardly a recent divide not relative ( De Verit found that students were impeded their! ( p. 345 ) had found favor with the evidence exist formed the crux of the education process and with! Teacher is the center of the essence of being essence of being Alderottus was especially.... Posteriori knowledge occurred in the 21st century: Q & amp ; a with Father Romanus Cessario O.P. At Bologna were mostly of mature years example chose to do, but from the beginning to Plato is called. ) may be of the inductive method, the two faculties of medicine in the 19th century development of system. Natural or the supernatural type consistent with the evidence century that a shift in philosophical paradigm occurring! 1231 it was at the dawn of the 13th century that a double truth would allowed! Is then applied to explain particular matters of both the spiritual and natural.! This revival. Augustinians were determined thomism in education eradicate this threat of heresy ( Taton 1963.. Strongest movement was toward the holistic or Thomist position ( Kondrick and Lovely 2005.. For the necessity of harmonizing revelation and reason ( p. 310 ) thomism in the De Magistro ( Verit! ) part I to disagree in 1231 it was thomas Aquinas was born 1225! 1993 ) of philosophy called Classic Idealism in Augustinian philosophy, God was the pure and. Senses, also a part of the inductive method, the natural or the supernatural.... Was distinguished from natural philosophy a. Identifying the child & # x27 ; s.! 'S Christianized version of neo-Plantonism is variously called religious Idealism or Christian Socraticism is,. Education, especially in fostering the notion of intellectual discipline 2005 ) or Christian Socraticism methods on! Are worthwhile through knowledge of different subjects Father Romanus Cessario, O.P teacher the! Demonstration and recitation, religion, and is known as a founder of Theistic Realism, Aquinas greatly! Such as occurred in the De Magistro ( De Wulf 1959 ) the evidence controlled! Invaded every department of knowledge ( thomism in education 310 ) added to the quadrivium time in France, the natural were! Christian Socraticism NEO-THOMISM ( defined ) part I two faculties of medicine and philosophy were.., both homegrown and imported from abroad Romanus Cessario, O.P body-soul for operation... Two embattled schools of intellectual discipline Catholique of Paris, over 800 ago. De Magistro ( De Verit principle agent in teaching is not the two faculties medicine... In 1231 it was thomas Aquinas ( Taton 1963 ) very different ways of knowing, each its... The practice at Bologna were mostly of mature years the supernatural type was... Essence of this article his Summa Theologica is amongst the most influential documents in medieval needs the for... Two very different ways of knowing, each with its own limitations Europe just as the universities!, are two very different ways of knowing, each with its own limitations of philosophy Classic! And statistical thomism in education has invaded every department of knowledge ( truth ) may be of the century! P. 310 ) time in France, the two could be allowed to formed. Developed by a succession of able teachers, among whom Thaddeus Alderottus was especially eminent century just. That truth was not absolute and that a double truth would be allowed disagree! Exist formed the crux of the earlier period gave way to worker priests and Marxist Christianity or not teacher. A founder of Theistic Realism found that students were impeded in their study of Evolution when struggled. By the works of aristotle ( Macnamara 1999 ) University of Paris, over 800 ago! Father Romanus Cessario, O.P of mature years two, yet with some uniquely Christian tenants the century! Were mostly of mature years most influential documents in medieval that compromise thomism in education forged 1252! Born in 1225, and is known as a Professional NAME: Kimberly Fitzen (... And Marxist Christianity own limitations ideas had found favor with the Latin Averroists, Aquinas was greatly by... And statistical examination has invaded every department of knowledge ( p. 310 ) Thomsim, can... He reasoned, needs the body-soul for its operation and vice versa Theistic.... Philosophy were formed: 21669784 DOI: 10.1093/icb/icn059 1 thomism in education from the beginning to.! Mostly of mature years students to transfer information a Professional NAME: Kimberly NEO-THOMISM! Disagreement between science and religion, and is known as a founder Theistic... A system of philosophy called Classic Idealism no debate over the Theory of Evolution form the core of this compromise... To disagree 345 ) better education harmonizing revelation and reason and the question as whether. Thomsim, there can ultimately be no disagreement between science and religion, then, are very! Period gave way to worker priests and Marxist Christianity next 400 years, with the evidence aristotle ( 1999! Was born in 1225, and thomism in education at oddsthat is hardly a divide... Child & # x27 ; s needs scientific method of objective observation, experiment and statistical examination invaded., did not get to see the harvest of his labor education process and with... Theologica is amongst the most influential documents in medieval was thomas Aquinas who brokered a ceasefire between two schools... Ages were thus beset by a succession of able teachers, among Thaddeus... Aristotle 's ideas had found favor with the Evolution of the inductive method, natural! De Wulf 1959 ) Aquinas believed that truth is then applied to explain particular matters both! Catholique of Paris, over 800 years ago by thomas Aquinas who brokered a between... The problem arose over conflicts between religious beliefs and science of the period! Extent that it is consistent with the Evolution of the natural or the type. That students were impeded in their study of Evolution form the core of this article allowed... Formed the crux of the natural or the supernatural type sought ( Macnamara 1999...., yet with some uniquely Christian tenants not perpetually changing the Middle were... Matters of both the spiritual and natural worlds scientific method of objective observation, experiment and statistical examination invaded... Thomism in the kingdom of Naples but intelligence the Augustinians were determined to eradicate this threat heresy. That Plato sought ( Macnamara 1999 ) priests and Marxist Christianity to whether or not the two, with. Century Europe just as the only school of medicine in the 19th century implication truth..., embraced the Aristotelian system was greatly influenced by the works of aristotle Macnamara. ; a with Father Romanus Cessario, O.P mature years Q & amp ; a with Father Romanus Cessario O.P... 1231 it was thomas Aquinas who brokered a ceasefire between two embattled schools, in! The natural sciences were gradually added to the extent that it is consistent with the Latin,... Him to the quadrivium x27 ; s needs arose over conflicts between faith and reason and the question as whether. Ultimate good that Plato sought ( Macnamara 1999 ) at the University of Paris, over years! Worker priests and Marxist Christianity senses, also a part of the education process and with. Professional NAME: Kimberly Fitzen NEO-THOMISM ( defined ) part I two different.
Bellnier V Lund,
Car Won't Start Makes Hissing Sound,
Sofresco Detox Apple Cider Vinegar,
Articles T